I just dunno!  On the one hand, it sounds really intriguing to have a special category each year.  But would that sort of exclude folks who don't have that particular craft talent?  Or maybe include more folks who might not otherwise join the fun?

Maybe I'm leaning toward leaving it open to anything as long as it's hand made, then everyone can join in.  But, having a theme sounds good, too!

Most crafts would lend themselves to making something along the theme wouldn't they?  Not that I DO either of these, but someone who does cross stitch could do something with a kitchen theme that year, and someone who carves could do a wooden spoon, for instance.  A soap maker could pretty much get in on any theme because whatever the theme we usually need to wash our hands, right?   

Obviously my opinion isn't worth much here – either way works for me!!  My craft skills are limited so will just have to use my imagination to make what little I do fit into a category, or sit it out that year, or learn a new skill!

LOL You are right…I actually found today a few ornaments I made last year..and they are bells..so they won't fit in a card.

The ones I made for this year do…I think that is why I got that idea.

But I still think we can run 2 exchanges…the one like we did last year, where the participants can make what they want as long as it is home made.

And the other with ornaments….I sign up for both I already know that