A Four Pie Day


Yesterday, I rose before the chickens to take Morgan to school for a pre-dawn bus departure on a rewards trip to a theme park then came home, milked the cow, tended the other animals, ran chickens off the porch, wrote my newspaper column, worked on my website, and baked four pies. Today is my cousin’s annual ham and bean country supper held at the old farmhouse. When I lived there, it was a gigantic task each year to get my stuff out of the way as the party takes over the whole place. I still take part in the tradition, even though I don’t live there anymore. This year, I was tasked with making Georgia’s pies. Pinto Bean Pie and Cornmeal Pie have long been a staple of the country supper scene. (Next thing you know they’ll be showing up at trendy gourmet restaurants along with ramps.)

I made four, count ’em, four pies. Two of each.

If you want a sense of accomplishment, bake four pies.

Pinto Bean Pie, obviously, centers around an unusual dessert ingredient–pinto beans. One cup of mashed pinto beans goes into each pie. The beans are cooked without seasoning.

I drained and mashed. The beans seemed a little dry. The recipe didn’t indicate whether or not you were to add water when mashing. That’s the trouble with some of these recipes from older ladies. They think you already know what you’re doing.

I called the pie hotline (Georgia).

My cousin’s wife, Sheryl, posted the recipe on Farm Bell, but she’s never baked it herself. Georgia’s been making these pies year after year after year, spreading their simple goodness and glory all over the county.

I asked Georgia if I was supposed to add water to the beans while I was mashing them. She said, “I don’t remember.”

I asked her who she got the recipe from originally, and she said, “I don’t remember.”

I asked her who the president was. She said Obama. (JUST CHECKING.)

We’re just glad now that she wrote the recipe down.

Robbed of further assistance, I made the command decision to add a little bit of water, just enough to make the beans mash up easier.

The instructions said to add this or that alternately, but having already veered off into the la-la land of making up my own directions, I dumped it all in together and mixed it up with the electric mixer. I didn’t even beat the eggs separately first.

(I’m doubling the recipe here for two pies.)

Baking four pies is a big job, and a little stressful in the midst of a busy day (I went to my cousin’s son’s high school graduation in the evening, too), but there’s also something relaxing about it that’s similar to punching the dough in making bread. With pie, it’s the rhythm of the rolling.

If you buy pre-fab pie crusts, you’re missing the best part of making pie.

The pinto bean filling turns out looking like a cross between a pumpkin pie and a pecan pie as the small bits of bean that weren’t completely mashed resemble nuts. If you use a food processor, you could get the beans blended completely smooth. I like the look of the bean bits.

Despite its primary ingredient, it’s a sweet, delicious pie that doesn’t taste a bit like beans.

I bake pies on the bottom rack, whether the instructions say so or not. It guarantees a well-baked crust without over-browning the top. There’s nothing worse than soggy crust.

Cornmeal Pie is another oddball dessert. Like Pinto Bean Pie, it’s a custard-type pie, with the unusual ingredient in this case being 1/2 cup cornmeal. (Use fresh stone-ground cornmeal for the best flavor.) The filling is boiled before being poured into the pie shell to soften the cornmeal.

It has a nutty taste, even without adding nuts, but you can mix in some pecans if you want. I didn’t use nuts, but if I did, I think I would use 1/2 cup per pie.

Remember when baking custard pies, the filling continues to set as the pie cools, so don’t over-bake.

By the way, 52 managed to come up with one of my heart’s desires, an old blue half gallon jar.

And he didn’t even have to steal it from Georgia. If he had, he’d be dead cuz she’d have whopped him one.
She’s pretty rowdy sometimes.

Pinto Bean Pie and Cornmeal Pie are both hardcore, old-fashioned, Southern-style treats created out of necessity by women with low budgets and basic ingredients who knew how to make anything taste like it fell out of Heaven. They’re the best of what a pie should be–simple, comforting, delicious.

Get the recipes:

Georgia’s Pinto Bean Pie
Georgia’s Cornmeal Pie
Foolproof Pie Crust


  1. SuzieQ says:

    I WANT ME SOME PIE!!! :dancingmonster:

  2. kathy says:

    😀 You never cease to amaze me. Just when I thought I’d recently heard of the oddest pie I’d ever heard of, a grapefruit pie, here you come up with pinto bean and cornmeal! How or what do they taste like? You did get a slice didn’t you? And as far as accomplishments, I think most of your days are pretty accomplished.

  3. Connie Rogers says:

    Suzanne ramps are in fine restaurants now..My girlfriend that lives in Wisconsin went to a restaurant that served them and she knew about them because of me..anyhow she tried them and liked them..she said they were expensive..Lucky us I get all the ramps I can eat for free..Connie

  4. CindyP says:

    I’ve got some pinto beans in the fridge — soaked WAY too many! I need to try this! Wondering on the taste myself….I need to come up with a new name so the SO will eat it (he’s a bean hater!)

  5. Diane says:

    Amazing. Really. A bean pie, a corn meal pie. And sweet too?? I got to try these. They do look good. I wonder if my family would eat the bean pie?? I might not tell them what is in it. lol.

  6. Pete says:

    Might just have to call them “Suzanne’s Pie” or “Georgia’s Pie” or “WV Pie” to get your families to eat them!! What a great way to get your veggies…

  7. Leah says:

    Umm, I love custard type pies and had never heard of the bean or cornmeal pies. Georgia knows whats good doesnt she? :hungry:

  8. Barbee' says:

    Oh, Suzanne, thank goodness you are there to rescue all these treats before the older generation forgets them completely. What a loss that would be. I used to wonder how my mother-in-law (for example) could have forgotten this or that. But, believe me, I now understand. I am coming along right behind her with the problem. Those are beautiful pies. That cornmeal pie sounds a bit like our chess pie. It has a little, not much, cornmeal in it.

  9. Brenda E says:

    Well that’s all well and good but what did you do in your SPARE time???? WOW

  10. Jennifer Robin says:

    Love the tip about baking pies on the bottom rack! I am totally jealous of that jar too. I have a quart size one, but a half gallon?!!

  11. IowaCowgirl says:

    Very cool post. Heirloom recipes are a treasure, as are those who save them.

  12. rileysmom says:

    Gosh Suzanne! ALL that in one day?! You must sleep well! What kind of vitamins do you take?

  13. Patricia Herman says:

    OMG those pies look delicious. Four pies in one day Suzanne you are my hero! Enjoy them….

  14. joycee says:

    True Southern pies and hopefully the Georgia’s of the world will share the recipes before they disappear from potluck tables. That would be a travesty!

  15. MAYBELLINE says:

    Sheezam! Those look and sound great. Do you think pre baking the crusts would be okay? Thanks for the inspiration.

  16. lavenderblue says:


  17. ML says:

    Those pies look delicious! And what a great tip about baking pies on the bottom rack. I never thought about that, but it makes sense. I’m always amazed at how much you get done everyday!

  18. Sylvia Adams says:

    :purpleflower: Very glad to have found the old fashioned cornmeal pie recipe Can’t wait to try it out!!

Add Your Thoughts