Holiday Free Book Friday #4: Good Tree/Bad Tree


Which Christmas tree is ours? This tree (Tree 1)………

……..or this tree (Tree 2)?

One winner will be chosen among the correct guessers to win……THEIR PICK of three autographed books from my contemporary backlist! :mrgreen:


  1. Sasha says:

    I guess Tree number 2!!!

  2. ruby55 says:

    What a choice you’re getting us to make with good tree/bad tree!

    However, like Sasha I’ll go for #2. It makes more sense for you to:

    a) leave the bottom branches free of ornaments for damaging, batting paws and hungry mouths.

    b) leave plenty of room under the tree to be able to pile up all those lovely presents for 5 people or more, depending on whether you’ll have guests for THE event.

    Actually, πŸ’‘ you may even have both: #1 in an animal-restricted area and #2 in an area that everybody can enjoy.:yes:

  3. Carol says:

    I’ll also say #2.

    May one of the trees was from last year!:lol:

  4. Carol says:

    OK, I meant to say Maybe! πŸ˜‰

  5. Fannie M Wiggins says:

    I say 2. I don’t know why. They are both so pet friendly. I wish I could send you a picture of my tree. I would go so far as to say it’s my prettiest tree ever.Have a Merry Christmas everyone and get lots of goodies. Hugs.:razz:

  6. StDebb says:

    My son votes for #2, because he says the background looks like your kids’ playroom. So I’m going with his vote, even though I, myself, was leaning the other way.


  7. Christy says:

    I’ll say tree #1 just because no one else has.

  8. Michelle says:

    I’m going to say both! πŸ™‚

  9. Jennifer says:

    Tree one with the space between the branches looks a little like a Charlie Brown tree.

    I’ll guess tree two because the bottom is cleared for Buttercup.

  10. Cheryl S. says:

    I’m going with tree #1. I don’t know why.

  11. Danica says:

    Im thinking that tree #1 is the one you wish for yourself, and sadly, like the others, I fear that Buttercup rules your home and makes it necessary to keep all temptations off the lower branches. So #2 is your tree

  12. Beth says:

    i gotta say Tree #1. Its unique and it’s actually has presents under it.

    Unlike my house, where the tree is still in its box but at least the stockings were hung. LOL

  13. Maureen says:

    I pick tree #2. Whichever tree is yours I hope you have a wonderful Christmas.

  14. Melissa says:

    Tree #2

    I’m back from Vegas. :thumbsup: Had a great time! Perhaps too much of a great time…:wink:

  15. Jennifer Yates says:

    At first I thought both, but I am not really sure…I’ll just say #1 (maybe).

    Have a great Christmas!!!!

  16. Ashley says:

    You didn’t say we couldn’t do it, so I say BOTH! πŸ™‚

  17. Elizabeth says:

    I think both!

  18. Laurie says:

    Merry Christmas!! Whichever tree it really is…I’m going with #2 just because I personally like fuller, thicker trees. If they’re both yours I’d say wow are you ever organized!! Hope your cat behaves too!

  19. Kim says:

    hmmm…tough choice..OK, #1. Really have no idea. LOL

  20. Alyssa says:

    I’m going with Tree #2, although I can’t really explain why I think it’s that one.


  21. catslady says:

    LOL I feel so sorry for tree No. 1 but my oldest daughter would love it. I’ll go with tree No. 2 – it has potential:lol:

  22. Cindi says:

    I am going with tree #2 cause well just cause…..


  23. TeresaH says:

    Hmmm…tough choice…
    I’ll go with Number 1, mainly because it has had less guesses! :rotfl:

  24. MartyK says:

    Tree one? I didn’t get to put up my all polar bear tree this year…but I did get another couple new ornaments! Have a wonderful and safe holiday!

  25. Estella says:

    I think tree #2, because the bottom is bare for Buttercup. Happy Holidays!

  26. Tori says:

    I’ll say…. um… #1. I think. Maybe. πŸ™‚

  27. Stacey115 says:

    I would say both. If I had to chose, I would go with number two. I have three cats. Tree number one would be down in less than an hour. :rolleyes:

  28. Lis says:

    After thoughtful discussion with my dad πŸ™‚ we’re going with both trees are yours.

    Merry Christmas & Happy Holidays! :bananadance:

  29. Robyn says:

    I think both are yours; the kids decorated one and you(and maybe the kids) decorated the other. They are each in a different room.

  30. BJ Deese says:

    Merry Christmas, Suzanne! I’m picking tree #2. πŸ™‚

  31. Gina says:

    #2! Merry Christmas!

  32. Marcy says:

    Tree #1. :thumbsup: